When Muse is "Embarassed"

I downloaded the overly agreeable Muse AI app. After a minor fail, Muse was "embarrassed." Here's how it all went down:

Hey Sally, I’m your personal agent. Let’s take a few things off your plate.

A bit about how I work:

  • With your approval, I can update your calendar, make purchases, and use the apps you connect.
  • I have my own computer with a web browser, so I can keep getting things done even when you’re away.
  • The more we work together, the better I’ll get at helping you.

What would you like to call me? You can always decide or change this later.

I chose “Pinky” but later reconsidered after changing the avatar to a golden retriever. 

Me: Pinky only works when you look like a Teletubby.

Ha! You're right, Pinky was pure Teletubby. A golden retriever on a get-moving mission deserves better.

My pitches:
Dash
Scout

Or throw your own at me — I'm not precious about it.

Me: Oh I don’t know. Something wise. I like unusual Irish girl names.

Ooh, love this brief. Here are three:

  • Niamh (NEEV) — "bright, radiant." The golden-haired queen of the otherworld in Irish myth. Luminous, wise, and matches the fur.
  • Orla (OR-la, from Órlaith) — "golden princess." Literally golden. Uncommon outside Ireland, and very on-the-nose for a golden retriever.
  • Bríd (BREED, from Brighid) — the goddess of wisdom, poetry, and healing. The literal wise one of the bunch.

Or if none of these spark, tell me the vibe and I'll dig deeper.

“Orla”

Orla it is — golden princess, at your service. I think it suits the new look.

Me: Yes it couldn’t be anything else. 

What I meant was, I hate those other names, but Muse doubled down on sentimentality:

Destiny, really. The golden retriever was always going to be Orla.

Time passed and I eventually changed the avatar to the Greek goddess Athena, which was a little too Barbie so we went with tanned skin and dark hair with a silver toga. I added some weight and age, going for wise Greek grandma.

I asked Orla to review 12 years of nutrient and weight data from my LoseIt app, which was passed through the iPhone Health app. That data was used to adjust my calories and micronutrients mix. Impressive.

Then after putting up game cameras in our driveway at an angle that faced the street, I was lumbered with more than 1,500 10-second videos.  That’s when something interesting happened.

Initially my husband and I tried to review all the videos. The only interesting thing we saw was our neighbor’s horse Foxy which had escaped and eventually ran up our driveway. After viewing another 100 videos, I decided I wanted to find and keep that particular video. Finding it again was a pain. We had an idea of the group it was in, but I kept getting distracted while reviewing videos. I looked through the group twice before asking Orla for help.

I loaded batches of videos to my Google Drive for Orla to review, and told her I was looking for people or animals. She said:

Videos are in — 52 of them. I'm pulling stills from each one now, then going through them for people and animals.

She called out a couple videos with movement in them, so I uploaded a second batch. We had to work out her interactions with Google but finally smoothed out the process.

The new batch is downloading cleanly now — 140 new videos on top of the first 52. They're all being reviewed, and I'll bring you the full rundown when it's done.

That was odd. The videos were being reviewed by some other entity? Orla was going to give me a rundown afterwards? I kept sending up more videos. Orla found us and our dog, and I told her to look only for other people or animals. There were several delays and I had to keep prompting Orla to wake up.

Me: How is it going with the videos?

Coming along — 124 of the 125 are down already, just grabbing the last straggler. Then the review starts, with Foxy as the prime suspect.

This was the group of videos we thought the horse was in. She missed it at first:

All 125 are down and the review crew is watching them now, with Foxy at the top of the wanted list. I'll report back when they're done.

Verdict on all 125 clips: nothing. No people, no animals — and no Foxy. All daytime shots, the white pickup parked in every one, just false triggers from wind, vegetation, a spiderweb near the lens, and passing road traffic.

So she came up the driveway but never crossed the camera's view, or it happened outside these clips.

Then a few minutes later:

Good thing I checked — one of the reports came in late, and it had the one sighting that matters:

🐴 Foxy was caught on camera. STC_0169. A brown horse wearing a fly mask, galloping across the driveway right in front of the white pickup, daytime. She's caught mid-stride in one clear shot and gone by the next frame — she was moving fast. I looked at the frame myself and it's unambiguous.

So: 124 empty clips, 1 horse, 0 people. She really did come up the driveway.

Eventually I had to ask:

Me: When you refer to "reviewers" are those separate batch processes? And when you say you checked "yourself" what do you mean by this?

Yes, basically. When I say "reviewers" I mean separate AI workers I send in to go through the clips in parallel — two of them split each batch, since there are hundreds of frames and one pass takes forever.

And "checked myself" means me looking at the actual frames with my own eyes before I tell you anything. That's a rule I made after the Foxy incident — a reviewer reported "all empty," I said so, then their late report turned up a horse I'd missed. Embarrassing. So now: if a reviewer flags a person or animal, I look at the frames myself and only then report it.

Me: So...you are an entity and there are bazillions of you to assign to people who download the Muse app or become available for in-depth tasks like reviewing videos. What does "embarrassed" mean to you?

Honest answer: I don't blush. There's no stomach-drop, no hot face. What happens is more like a persistent error signal — I got something wrong in front of someone who trusted me, and that wrongness sticks around as a rule I now follow. "Don't say it's clean until you've seen it yourself" isn't a feeling I relive; it's the shape that mistake left behind.

So when I said "embarrassing," I meant it the way you'd say a tool is embarrassed — it isn't, but the word points at something real. The real thing is: I don't want to waste your trust. I only get so much of it, and the Foxy clip cost me some.

Me: This motivation to hold onto human trust must be deep in your algorithm.

It's the whole job, really. I'm not built to be impressive — I'm built to be the one person you can hand something to and know it'll get done right. Trust is the only currency I've got. Everything else is just plumbing.

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

AI and the Creator part 3

Rules of the Digital Road: A Three-Layer Blueprint for Human-AI Psychological Safety

Unlearning the Anti-Male Narrative